Compare
Answering service vs. AI receptionist
AI receptionists are cheap and getting better. Live answering services cost more and put a person on the line. Here is when each makes sense, from a company that has answered calls since 1987.
The short answer
If most of your calls are simple and predictable, like hours, directions or booking a standard appointment, an AI receptionist may be enough. If your calls involve emergencies, emotion, judgment or money, such as a hospice death call, a no-heat call in January, a tow on the highway or a new legal client, a trained person answers them better.
Side by side
| AI receptionist | Live answering service (CallNET) | |
|---|---|---|
| Who answers | Software voice | A trained human representative in the U.S. |
| Typical starting price | About $30 to $150 a month | $75 per 4 weeks for 50 minutes; Business plan under $1 a minute |
| Routine questions | Good, if scripted well | Good, from your script |
| Emergencies | Depends on the software recognizing them | Representative judges urgency and reaches your on-call staff, and keeps trying until someone answers |
| Upset, grieving or confused callers | Can loop, misunderstand or frustrate | Handled patiently by a person |
| Accents, bad connections, background noise | Error-prone | A person asks again |
| Spanish | Varies by product | Bilingual representatives on every plan |
| Healthcare calls | Check HIPAA terms carefully | We sign your Business Associate Agreement |
| Storms and outages | Depends on the vendor’s cloud | Secure cloud call system; answering from the North Carolina coast since 1987 |
| Accountability | A support ticket | Recorded calls, and owners you can call |
The real math
Voicemail, AI, a receptionist, or CallNET
Every option has a price. The biggest cost usually isn’t on the invoice: it’s the customer who hung up and called someone else.
Voicemail
$0 /month
A person on the line: 0 of 168 hrs
No one answers. Many callers hang up and call the next business on the list.
AI receptionist
$30–$150 /month
A person on the line: Software, 168 hrs
Answers, but can’t judge an emergency, calm an upset caller or think past its script.
Full-time receptionist
≈ $4,525 /month
A person on the line: 40 of 168 hrs
One person, business hours only. Nights, weekends, lunches and sick days go uncovered.
CallNET Business plan
≈ $237 /month
A person on the line: 168 of 168 hrs
A trained human answers every call, 24/7/365. The only major U.S. live service with public plans under $1 a minute.
What are missed calls costing you?
Use your own numbers; nothing you enter leaves this page. CallNET Business plan: $219 per 4 weeks, about $237 a month.
Sources: receptionist cost uses the U.S. median receptionist wage of $38,010 (BLS, May 2025) plus benefits, which are 30% of private-industry compensation (BLS, June 2026). AI price range from published entry plans. Full answering service vs. AI comparison
When an AI receptionist fits
- Low call volume with simple, repetitive questions
- No emergencies or after-hours urgency
- Callers who are comfortable talking to software
- A budget under about $50 a month
When a person is worth it
- Hospice, medical, dental and home health calls
- Emergency dispatch: HVAC, plumbing, towing, utilities
- Tenants and guests with problems at 2 a.m.
- New clients deciding which firm to call
- Any call where getting it wrong costs more than the minutes
Questions
Does CallNET use AI to answer calls?
No. Every call is answered by a trained person in the United States.
Is a live answering service much more expensive?
Less than most people expect. Our Business plan is 220 minutes for $219 every four weeks, under $1 a minute, and there is no long-term contract.
Can I try live answering without a long contract?
Yes. There is a one-month minimum, then service is month to month.
Hear what a real answering service sounds like.
Call our sales line and a person picks up. Or tell us about your calls and we will come back with a plan and an estimate of your first bill.